Sorry for the delay folks. Let’s get right to the third measure we desperately need to save our country.
Patch 3: Repeal the 17th amendment and restore the election of Senators to the state legislatures.
When the Constitution was first ratified, Article 1 Section 3 originally said this about how Senators would be elected: “The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State, chosen by the Legislature thereof…” In 1913, the 17th amendment was ratified. The 17th amendment modified the Constitution as originally drafted by changing the above italicized words to “elected by the people thereof”. Originally the Founders intended that the House of Representatives would be directly elected by the people (hence being “representatives”), the Senate by the state governments (functioning as representatives for the state governments), and the President by essentially aristocrats (those best qualified to choose a superb executive). Among the results of this system was the reality that radical movements of the people were unable to immediately transform the entire government. If the people really wanted something completely changed, it would take a sustained 6-year movement at the least.
Stop for a moment and appreciate the wisdom of the Founders’ intent. Have you ever bought something on impulse that you regret? Well of course you have. I’m ashamed to admit how many times I’ve wasted money on things I thought were too good to pass on. Have you ever made friends with someone and after a few years learned that they were someone completely different than you thought they were? Check. Making hasty decisions is an unfortunate tendency among us human folks. The same thing can happen when we vote. We may think that Candidate X is awesome because he’s saying all the right things and has a really cool coat and tie, but later we find out he’s a tax cheat, racist, or complete bumbling idiot and then we wish we could have our vote back.
In national elections, the 17th amendment has made it easier for people to “impulse buy” their politicians. To make matters worse, many states now require that members of the electoral college vote in accordance with the popular vote of their state. This effectively makes the House, Senate, and President all directly elected by the people. The Founders purposely built a system that required a long time to change and was selected by different (sometimes competing) segments of society. This allowed America to make adjustments more slowly and thoughtfully than we do right now.
I’d argue that the most recent election is a clear illustration of the need for a repeal of the 17th amendment. Sure, most Americans wanted Barack Obama to become President, but in hindsight, would most Americans really admit that having a massive Democrat majority in the House and a de facto super majority in the Senate is a good thing? There has been little to no debate as colossal spending packages continue to fly through. Now there is serious talk about nationalizing major sections of our financial system (just a few years we were all livid that Venezuela was doing the same thing!). I think we would have been far better off if Americans’ enthusiasm was tempered by the original system envisioned by the Constitution and people had at least 2 more years to seriously think about what’s going on.
As they say, patience is a virtue. Unfortunately, our system is designed to reward rash decision making and hero worship. Let’s can 17!